Zero Effect

Why doesn’t openSUSE use smart as a default package manager

Posted by: MeMo on: August 30, 2007

There is definitely something i’m not getting about this issue.

it’s known that since 10.1 and openSUSE suffers horrible bugs in it’s package management system and it’s the only distro that i know of that when installing it you get advised to totally dump your entire package management system and use a new one ie. SMART .

so why don’t they just put it as a default choice if users are comfortable with ?

I know that the GUI for smart is not good enough but the base system is just awesome .. some say it’s even better than Debian’s apt-get and Fedora’s Yum according to there case studies .

wasn’t it easier to integrate smart in Yast and creat a new GUI for it instead of creating a whole new system .

The new system may be good or even better than smart , BUT it’s new and it will need a lot of testing and loooong hours of hard working it’s just doesn’t make any sense to me.

I always loved openSUSE but just couldn’t get along with it’s pkg mgr and always reverted back to Ubuntu.

a lot of people including me are waiting for the new openSUSE 10.3 next month and honestly i think that this is openSUSE’s last chance , 3 versions in a raw with the same problems can’t be good at all .

4 Responses to "Why doesn’t openSUSE use smart as a default package manager"

1 | daP

August 30th, 2007 at 7:22 pm

Ever used smart on a x86_64 system?

I recommend you give it a shot - might give you a whole new perspective why its used by default.

2 | dosnlinux

September 1st, 2007 at 1:09 am

The only thing I can think of is that SUSE needs extra stability since it is an enterprise OS. The new system may not have as much testing, but Novell may be able to have as much control over the SMART product as they need.

Then again they may not use it because it’s Not Invented Here.

3 | Boycott Novell » Do-No-Evil Saturday: OpenSUSE Faster and Better, Novell’s Financial Results Lift Stock

September 1st, 2007 at 3:51 am

[...] in SuSE/SUSE (I’ve been in SuSE’s “RPM hell” since 2003). Here is one new complaint/suggestion and here is another possible milestone. The openSUSE 10.3 Beta 2 release brought down another [...]

4 | TuXero I

September 2nd, 2007 at 11:34 pm

Sorry guys i didn’t notice that comment moderation was turned on :S .
SMART is an open source project which means they can modify and controlo it as they wish and in any way ZMD which is the SLED tool has been removed from the community project .
“Then again they may not use it because it’s Not Invented Here” i thing you are right in this one as it’s the only rational explanation to the issue

Comments are closed.

Bookmark

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

ABOUT ME

MeMo
Welcome to my personal free zone .. this is where i say it all with no barriers or limits away from community hypocrisy. I'm an Egyptian Muslim Middle Eastern Liberal "NON-TERRORIST, for you prejudicial assholes " lonely guy who loves open source software .. About me ...

Find me :

Memoo Mo'men's Facebook profile Mo'men. Get yours at bighugelabs.com/flickr

Flickr Photos

Ship Next day

white

mediterranean 1

mediterranean 2

More Photos

Blog Stats

  • 50,350 hits

Things